Tuesday, November 25, 2008

Blog Two: Apocalypse Now Response (due 11/26 by midnight)

Please make some general comments in response to viewing this film (either halfway through or at the end). What cursory observations have you made in relationship to the novella?

2 comments:

Shawn Kronk said...

Alright, lots of differences are apparent between the film and novella. For instance the location: Heart of Darkness is set in Africa and Apocalypse Now is set in Vietnam. This difference alone makes the rest of the story fundamentally different in the movie, also making the parallels between the two difficult to detect. I believe that the change could be an appropriate one, seeing as both situations/environments could be psychologically traumatic. However, I feel as though the filmmaker added things that were more of a detriment than a benefit to conveying the seriousness of the subject. One such example of this was the character Lieutenant Colonel Kilgore – the surfer officer. Though I believe it’s possible to draw a parallel between his character and the clerk in Heart of Darkness (noted by Marlow for his ability to keep up a very European look and lifestyle), the character seems to add a sense of trifling frivolity to the nature of the war and its operations: a nuance that is much contradictory to the general tone meant to be accomplished by the film. Another element that I felt was poorly handled – if it ought to have been included at all – was the sexuality of the soldier’s R & R. If the argument were to be made that this was a significant symptom of the psychological effect of the environment of the soldiers, then it at least could have been handled more discreetly and still communicated the same idea. (Just for the record, I did fast forward through these parts, so maybe I missed some important reason that they were included… however, I highly doubt it.) Another thing that disappointed me with the film was the loss of Marlow’s apparent disgust with imperialism and his own “countrymen,” his fellow Europeans. Though the later is somewhat carried over into Captain Willard’s character in his disgust with his fellow soldiers’ hypocrisy (“We cut ‘em in half with a machine gun, and then give ‘em a Band-Aid. It was a lie.), the war’s consummation of him is very contrary to the utter revulsion to imperialism that dominates Marlow’s character. Overall, I’m not sure how much I appreciated the film’s effort at adapting Conrad’s concepts to a modern – and supposedly more relative – happening. Maybe with more review of the film this could change, but I’m not overly-zealous about seeking such a view of it.

AustinHoss said...

The film poses extreme differences to the novel. Shawn noted the most obvious ones, including the location. However the film still gives the same type of psychological dilemmas and traumatic situations that the book presents, therefore some comparisons can be drawn between the too. The story differs extremely, but the overall mental concepts still exist. I can't say a whole lot because I am still not very far into the movie.

So far I am really enjoying the film. I didn't really have any knowledge about it prior to viewing it for this class (which is odd for someone like me). I am excited to finish it.