Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Blog Five: Frankenstein (response due by 1/11 at 4 p.m.)

Please respond to these questions.

1. What is your initial impression of the movie(s) and the book? This is a general question, so you may be general in your answer, or you may choose to point out a specific aspect that caught your attention.

2. Specifically, how do you find the author's/producer's development of the mood and tone? Is it effective or not? Explain.

3. Assuming that you watch at least an excerpt from each movie, what do you find to be the most compelling difference between the two?

4. Explain to me what you plan to do for your comparison project and what you hope to accomplish with this project.

2 comments:

Shawn Kronk said...

1. My initial impression of the book was that it was rather bland. However, as the book progressed, it became very intriguing and offered some interesting insights on science and the human condition. The movie (1930s) gave me the impression of the modern stereotypical portrayal of Frankenstein...and indeed appered to be the source of this hackneyed misinterpretation of the novel.

2. I feel the author worked very developed the tone with much expertise. Shelly uses a melancholy, somber tone to create and iminent sense of dread, as well as to create a level of sympathy for her characters (specifially Victor Frankenstein). However, the movie's tone from the onset seemed to be more of a dark, creepy tone, that played off Dr. Frankenstein as a mad scientist I feel Shelly's choices may be more effective than those of the film's producer, since the sense of dread is constantly there, while the movie doesn't really accomplish much of a sense of fear.

3. I actually didn't watch any of the more modern film. After reading it's summary if appeared to have nothing to do with the novel, so I decided to just watch more of the older film.

4. We plan to recreate the scene where Frankenstein brings his monster to life. Our goal is to create the scene as it was described in the novel, rather than the manic "It's alive!" business that's become prevelant. Beyond that, I don't know exactly what Austin plans to do. All the stylistic and artistic license I left to his discretion, since he's better and more experienced with film editting, etc. than I am. However, I believe we also hope to create a tone more similar to that of Shelly's novel than that accomplished by the 30s film.

AustinHoss said...

1. Although I read through it at a rapid rate, I found the book to be relatively boring. It did catch my attention at certain points, generally the more climactic parts of the story, however it didn't hold my attention for long. I unfortunately didn't get to see the entire movie, therefore I cannot generate too much of an opinion on it. However, what I did see held my attention and kept me entertained.

2. The moral and psychological darkness of the book gave a rather interesting twist, however it wasn't an entertaining twist. The movie changed up this tone, giving the story a more science-fiction/horror feel. This gave Dr. Frankenstein a psychological dilemma, but not the same as the novel.

3. The movie's biggest difference from the novel is what I stated above, the science-fiction/horror tone it took instead of the psychological dark mood the book presented. As I said above, I unfortunately only saw an excerpt from the 30s film and wasn't able to see any of the new film.

4. Our project is an attempt to recreate a famous scene in the Frankenstein story. We are attempting to follow the book's rendition of the scene rather than the stereotypical scene that is almost always given.